Was today's SCOTUS ruling on Texas abortion laws good for health care safety standards? | The Tylt

FINAL RESULTS
Was today's SCOTUS ruling on Texas abortion laws good for health care safety standards?
A festive crown for the winner
#GoodWorkSCOTUS
#BadWorkSCOTUS

The Supreme Court just struck down a Texas law that looked as though it would close three-quarters of the state’s abortion clinics by putting new requirements on facilities and doctors. There were two provisions of the Texas law (known as HB2) at issue: the first required doctors at abortion clinics to have local admitting privileges at nearby hospitals. The second required all clinics to upgrade their facilities to hospital-grade standards. Nearly half of the clinics in Texas have already closed since the law was imposed in 2013 because they were unable to meet the new legal criteria. Texas legislators claimed the HB 2 laws were implemented to better patient safety, while opponents said the real aim was to severely reduce Texas women's access to abortion. 

Was today's SCOTUS ruling on Texas abortion laws good for American safety standards in healthcare?

The 5-3 ruling is the court’s first abortion decision in almost a decade, and abortion-rights advocates are calling it the most consequential Supreme Court ruling on this issue since 1992, when the court reaffirmed a constitutional right to end a pregnancy.

Reproductive rights groups applauded the ruling, claiming that Texas lawyers never proved the HB2 laws protected women's safety in any way.

Antiabortion groups are sharply criticizing the decision as a serious blow to the pro-life movement and to healthcare regulation. They believe abortion is murder and are opposed to it in almost all circumstances; they also say that HB2 laws were designed to reduce women's health risks and increase safety.

Was today's ruling good for American health care standards and women's safety?

Dataviz
Real-time Voting
Was today's SCOTUS ruling on Texas abortion laws good for health care safety standards?
#GoodWorkSCOTUS
#BadWorkSCOTUS
#GoodWorkSCOTUS
Hillary Clinton lauded the decision as a positive one for women's health.
#BadWorkSCOTUS
Many pro-life advocates said the decision legalizes violating safety standards.
#BadWorkSCOTUS
The conservative Heritage Foundation tweeted that the decision was a loss for women's safety.
#GoodWorkSCOTUS
The Court's majority opinion argued that HB 2 afforded women no real health or safety benefits.
#GoodWorkSCOTUS
And pro-choice leaders argue that laws like HB 2 were never about safety standards, but about reducing women's access to abortion.
#BadWorkSCOTUS
Texas's lieutenant governor called the decision a terrible one for the women of the Lone Star State
FINAL RESULTS
Was today's SCOTUS ruling on Texas abortion laws good for health care safety standards?
A festive crown for the winner
#GoodWorkSCOTUS
#BadWorkSCOTUS
© 2016 The Tylt
Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our  User Agreement,  Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement,   and  Your California Privacy Rights  (each updated 1/1/20).
© 2020 Advance Local Media LLC. All rights reserved (About Us).
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed,transmitted,cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local.