Is torture ever justified? | The Tylt

Is torture ever justified?

Gina Haspel, President Trump's nominee for CIA director, has come under fire for her involvement at torture sites during the Bush administration. Trump himself has called torture effective and morally defensible, and says he supports waterboarding. Civil rights advocates such as the ACLU have vehemently criticized the choice of Haspel, but others agree with Trump and say torture is sometimes justified. What do you think?

FINAL RESULTS
Politics
Is torture ever justified?
A festive crown for the winner
#TortureAlwaysWrong
#TortureJustifiable
Dataviz
Real-time Voting
Is torture ever justified?
#TortureAlwaysWrong
#TortureJustifiable
#TortureAlwaysWrong

In 2002, Haspel was part of the CIA's overseas detention sites in Thailand, where she oversaw brutal interrogations and later destroyed recordings of those interrogations. Advocacy groups like Amnesty International say her nomination shows this administration is completely comfortable with torture and violation of international law, and Haspel's record should disqualify her from leading the CIA.

As a clandestine officer at the Central Intelligence Agency in 2002, Gina Haspel oversaw the torture of two terrorism suspects and later took part in an order to destroy videotapes documenting their brutal interrogations at a secret prison in Thailand.
#TortureJustifiable

But Haspel is well-regarded within the CIA and the intelligence community. Many have applauded her selection, including former director of national intelligence James Clapper.

“I am very pleased to learn of Director Pompeo’s selection of Gina Haspel as Deputy Director. It speaks well of him for picking a seasoned veteran of the Agency who is widely and deeply respected by the workforce as well as those outside the Agency. She has the broad-gauged experience from both foreign and domestic assignments to serve as the right-arm for Director Pompeo."
#TortureAlwaysWrong

Critics say this pick just further cements the Trump administration's public indifference to human rights and the rule of law.

#TortureAlwaysWrong

Former prisoner of war and torture survivor Sen. John McCain spoke out against Haspel's nomination.

#TortureJustifiable

Others applauded the choice of Haspel. Many Americans take a realpolitik attitude towards our treatment of American enemies abroad, and think that while torture is unfortunate, it is probably sometimes necessary.

#TortureJustifiable
#TortureAlwaysWrong

Others point out beyond torture's moral indefensibility, the data shows it doesn't work.

An exhaustive 2014 report by the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence analyzed millions of internal CIA documents related to the torture of terrorism suspects, concluding that “the CIA's use of its enhanced interrogation techniques was not an effective means of acquiring intelligence or gaining cooperation from detainees.” It adds that “multiple CIA detainees fabricated information, resulting in faulty intelligence.”
Terrorists are real. Witches are not. But real or imagined, torture doesn't work.
FINAL RESULTS
Politics
Is torture ever justified?
A festive crown for the winner
#TortureAlwaysWrong
#TortureJustifiable