Should Confederate monuments be banned? | The Tylt

Should Confederate monuments be banned?

Tensions are running high in New Orleans as two opposing groups protest for and against the removal of three monuments to Confederate generals. The pro-removal camp says these statues honor white supremacy, and that anyone who betrayed the Union to defend slavery should not be put on pedestals by city or state governments. But others argue millions of Southerners' ancestors served and died in the Civil War, and their history should be honored, not erased. What do you think? 

FINAL RESULTS
Politics
Should Confederate monuments be banned?
A festive crown for the winner
#DontHonorTraitors
#SaveSouthernHeritage
Dataviz
Real-time Voting
Should Confederate monuments be banned?
#DontHonorTraitors
#SaveSouthernHeritage
#DontHonorTraitors

Led by an organization called Take 'Em Down NOLA, many New Orleans citizens are urging the city to remove all monuments to Confederate leaders. They say they are tired of being told to honor white supremacists who betrayed the U.S. government and started a war that resulted in the bloodiest conflict in American history. If people want to honor the Confederacy, they can do so on their own—but government buildings should have no part of it.

imageSupportingMedia
#SaveSouthernHeritage

But so many Southerners have relatives and ancestors who suffered and died in the Civil War, and they say their forebears were not fighting for slavery, but in defense of their families, their homeland, and their way of life. Taking down monuments to their sacrifices is deeply offensive to them.

"America, north and south, has a tradition of honoring its soldiers whether one believes in the war or not.... My hope is we Americans will forever honor ALL the warriors who were willing to suffer and die to serve their country."
imageSupportingMedia
#DontHonorTraitors

When former KKK leader and lifelong white supremacist David Duke is on your team, protesting on behalf of keeping Confederate monuments up? Perhaps it's time to rethink that whole #HeritageNotHate thing.

imageSupportingMedia
#SaveSouthernHeritage

Businessman Frank Stewart took out a two-page ad in the New Orleans Advocate lambasting New Orleans Mayor Mitch Landrieu’s efforts to remove the Confederate monuments, and urging angry protesters to "forgive and move on:"

Should the Pyramids in Egypt be destroyed since they were built entirely from slave labor? What about the Roman Coliseum? Everyone involved needs to put down their personal prejudices and let the magnificent memorials of real history remain as a permanent reminder to all that the consequences of conflict and the results of positive evolution of life and mankind should not be forgotten.
#SaveSouthernHeritage

Many defenders of Confederate monuments say they just want to honor veterans, not celebrate slavery.

#DontHonorTraitors
FINAL RESULTS
Politics
Should Confederate monuments be banned?
A festive crown for the winner
#DontHonorTraitors
#SaveSouthernHeritage