Should America be forced to pay a carbon tax? | The Tylt

FINAL RESULTS
Should America be forced to pay a carbon tax?
#MakeAmericaPay
A festive crown for the winner
#BadDealBadSolution

President-elect Trump seems intent on removing the U.S. from the Paris Agreement on climate change. Trump believes climate change is a hoax and the treaty burdens American workers with costly regulations. Europe is considering a costly "carbon tax" on American imports if the U.S. backs out. Since America's carbon emissions impact the whole world, some say it's only fair. Others argue the deal is hypocritical and any tariffs could spark an unnecessary trade war. What do you think? Vote below!

Dataviz
Real-time Voting
Should America be forced to pay a carbon tax?
#MakeAmericaPay
#BadDealBadSolution

The Paris Agreement is a landmark treaty negotiated by 197 countries designed to reduce and mitigate climate change. The agreement has a goal of preserving the global climate below 2°C above pre-industrial levels. 

There are no arbitrary goals for individual countries, but rather nations are responsible for drafting sustainable, realistic plans to reduce carbon emissions and present them to the U.N. every five years. There will be an auditing system to ensure governments are not cooking the books, and financial incentives to ensure poorer nations are not disproportionately impacted. Nations are required to create an inventory system accounting for human-made emissions, which some right-leaning organizations see as just another set of onerous environmental regulations. Adding to conservatives' concerns with the deal, certain language in the agreement was deliberately drafted to avoid triggering approval by the U.S. Senate.

The U.S. is the number two polluter in the world and by exiting the agreement, America could endanger any future climate change negotiations. To prevent that from happening, several European nations are threatening costly carbon taxes on American goods—but that could potentially plunge the global economy into a trade war.

imageSupportingMedia
#MakeAmericaPay

The U.S. doesn't have to do much to satisfy its end of the Paris Agreement, but if Trump pulls out, the Europeans will have few options to fight back. America is responsible for almost 18 percent of the world's carbon emissions, shouldn't it pay for the damage it wreaks on the environment?

And yet, as the independent analytical team at Climate Action Tracker (CAT) put it, “the U.S. climate plans are at the least ambitious end of what would be a fair contribution.”
#BadDealBadSolution

This was a bad deal and America needs to be thinking about its own interests, especially while China and India continue to spew tons of carbon emissions into the air with few repercussions. Why must the U.S. be so responsible, but other nations not so much? People are hurting here, and we need to focus on our own people before we start committing to lofty, progressive pie-in-the-sky goals. Strapping businesses with more regulations is only going to hurt the American worker.

"Any regulation that's outdated, unnecessary, bad for workers or contrary to the national interest will be scrapped and scrapped completely," Mr Trump said. "We're going to do all this while taking proper regard for rational environmental concerns."
#MakeAmericaPay

Yes, but America cannot ignore its responsibility as the world's number two polluter. Operating without regard for the environment would give America an unfair competitive advantage, and thus a carbon tax is a totally appropriate response. Our planet should not be sacrificed to appease quarterly earnings expectations and self-interested shareholders.

Countries imposing costs on their own industries to control carbon emissions could tell the World Trade Organization that United States industries are operating under an unfair trade advantage by avoiding any cost for their pollution.
#BadDealBadSolution

Why should the American people, hard-working families and entrepreneurs, be hit with a carbon tax for a deal they had no say in? This was shoved down the throats of the American people, with no respect for the Congress or the checks-and-balances that make our country great. If the U.N. wants a climate deal, it should come back to the table with a President who will bring any deal to the Senate floor for approval. 

We didn't ask for this, and we didn't get a say in it.

If a deal can be reached, Obama will have to trust that Communist China — the world’s most prodigious carbon emitter — will voluntarily implement economic restraints about 30 years from now, by which time the U.S. will have to reach a 26 to 28 percent reduction in greenhouse-gas emissions. Obama will implement regulations to get that done unilaterally. So China will have more of a say in what happens to our environmental policy than Congress. Obama will also negotiate with a number of other unsavory despots, such as the homicidal Robert Mugabe, who represents the African position at the Paris negotiations. He will not, however, bring the deal to Congress, which represents the majority of the American people.
#MakeAmericaPay

The expectations of America in regards to the Paris Agreement are peanuts. To scrap the deal out of some rigid ideology isn't just foolish, it's destructive. A potential trade war is far more damaging than forcing companies to be transparent about carbon emissions. Trump would be pissing off global superpowers like China. And France has been very specific about a 1 to 3 percent carbon tax if Trump doesn't hold up America's end of the deal.

“The Chinese are already warning that if Trump were to pull out, he would be defying the wishes of the entire planet. The Chinese are pretty clear that they have no intention of walking away,” Stern told me. “I think you’re going to see that all over, other countries are going to be furious with us. It’s not like, ‘oh, the U.S. isn’t there, we’ll go ahead anyway.’ No. They’re going to be furious, but I don’t think they’ll walk off.”
#BadDealBadSolution

What hypocrisy! France is threatening to hit America with a carbon tax for walking out of an agreement that it refuses to honor. Again, why is America being picked on when these countries are failing to live up to their end of the bargain?

Despite the threats, even France itself isn’t complying with its own Paris global warming agreement promises. A labor union successfully pressured the French government to roll back the Paris carbon tax earlier this month, because such a tax would have shut down several coal power plants in Paris operated by its members.
FINAL RESULTS
Should America be forced to pay a carbon tax?
#MakeAmericaPay
A festive crown for the winner
#BadDealBadSolution
© 2016 The Tylt
Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our  User Agreement,  Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement,   and  Your California Privacy Rights  (each updated 1/1/20).
© 2020 Advance Local Media LLC. All rights reserved (About Us).
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed,transmitted,cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local.