Is it wrong to punch a Nazi? | The Tylt

Is it wrong to punch a Nazi?

When white supremacist Richard Spencer was sucker-punched on Inauguration Day, the Internet had a field day. But is it wrong to cheer violence, even when it's committed against a Nazi? Some say after Charlottesville, it's clear American fascists are here for violence, not dialogue—these are evil people who must be met with force. Others argue meeting free speech, even repugnant speech, with violence sets a disturbing precedent and doesn't solve the problem. What do you think? 👊

FINAL RESULTS
Politics
Is it wrong to punch a Nazi?
A festive crown for the winner
#NazisNeedPunching
#ChooseNonViolence
Dataviz
Real-time Voting
Is it wrong to punch a Nazi?
#NazisNeedPunching
#ChooseNonViolence
#ChooseNonViolence

 Writer Andrew Sharp argues anti-fascists demonstrators need to adhere to higher standards and should not be dragged down to the level of fascists.

We must confront neo-Nazis and other racists and their wrong ideas – but you don’t defeat Nazis by becoming like them.
Fascists want to upend our laws and order. You don’t counter that by taking the law into your own hands by punching a Nazi. It might feel good, but it’s called assault and battery, and we used to condemn that.  
#NazisNeedPunching

Others say that's bullshit, especially after the tragic death of an innocent protestor in Charlottesville. There's no talking to genocidal maniacs who advocate the mass murder of American minorities. Plus, punching Nazis is arguably an American folk hero tradition. Indiana Jones did it, Captain America did it—even the Blues Brothers made the Illinois Nazis jump off a bridge. 

Yes, we are a society of laws—but Warren Ellis argues our laws don't apply to people who seek to destroy the ideals of peaceful democracy:

"Yes, it is always correct to punch Nazis. They lost the right to not be punched in the face when they started spouting genocidal ideologies that in living memory killed millions upon millions of people….Nazis do not need a hug. Nazis do not need to be indulged. Their agenda is always, always, extermination."
#NazisNeedPunching
#NazisNeedPunching

Even those who generally support pacifism and nonviolent solutions to political problems were given pause by the violence and murder in Charlottesville.

#ChooseNonViolence

Others maintain nonviolent solutions are the best way to confront fascism. Punching feels good but doesn't solve the problem.

#NazisNeedPunching

But those who are for punching Nazis say the time for conversation is long gone. Violence is the only language genocidal fascists understand.

#ChooseNonViolence

But the issue of free speech complicates the matter. Sure, it might feel great to punch a Nazi. They definitely deserve it. But does hitting people who express repugnant, genocidal views serve to justify future violence against any kind of free speech? Will it drive them underground, which is arguably much more dangerous? How much protection do people who advocate for genocide deserve?

Where do we draw the line?

FINAL RESULTS
Politics
Is it wrong to punch a Nazi?
A festive crown for the winner
#NazisNeedPunching
#ChooseNonViolence