Is Kurt Cobain overrated? | The Tylt

Is Kurt Cobain overrated?

February 20 would have been Kurt Cobain's 50th birthday. As the founder of Nirvana, Cobain undoubtedly changed the direction of popular music forever—but some argue the cult of Kurt only developed because of his tragic suicide in 1994. Others call him a legend, an icon, and a reluctant hero. Does Kurt Cobain deserve to be deified? 

FINAL RESULTS
Entertainment
Is Kurt Cobain overrated?
#CobainIsOverrated
A festive crown for the winner
#RespectKurtCobain
Dataviz
Real-time Voting
Is Kurt Cobain overrated?
#CobainIsOverrated
#RespectKurtCobain
#RespectKurtCobain

Nirvana broke open grunge to the wider world, and "Smells Like Teen Spirit" became the anthem of a generation. Like Lou Reed and James Brown, Kurt Cobain actually changed the direction of popular music. Rolling Stone called him one of the hundred greatest songwriters of all time: 

"Nirvana's skull-crushing noise assault would have meant little if not for the deceptively brilliant pop craft underpinning it."
imageSupportingMedia
#CobainIsOverrated

But critics say Cobain owes much of his revered status to his tragic suicide—he wasn't a technically great guitarist, and Nirvana didn't produce very much music. They think his rebel image was bullshit and his fabled lyrics were trite:

I never really bought into Kurt’s retroactive deification, either. From a musical standpoint, Kurt was clearly the least talented of his bandmates, and his faux-philosophical, anti-Guns N Roses, new-new-wave, ultra-liberal shtick more or less opened the floodgates for a million, billion wusses like Trent Reznor and that crybaby from Radiohead to make miserable, woe-is-me alternative the default setting for mainstream rock to this day.
imageSupportingMedia
#RespectKurtCobain

Kurt Cobain's fans argue our entire musical landscape is different (and better) because of him.

#RespectKurtCobain

 For millions of people, Cobain symbolized the counterculture and the ethos of staying true to yourself.

#RespectKurtCobain

He is categorized with the ultimate legends of rock 'n roll.

#CobainIsOverrated

Others don't believe the hype.

#CobainIsOverrated

Some people are over the cult of Nirvana and Kurt.

#CobainIsOverrated

And others say Cobain suicide is the reason for his canonization. They argue if Eddie Vedder had shot himself, he and Pearl Jam would be regarded as the ultimate gods of grunge, not Nirvana.

FINAL RESULTS
Entertainment
Is Kurt Cobain overrated?
#CobainIsOverrated
A festive crown for the winner
#RespectKurtCobain