Are you excited for the return of 'Doctor Who'? | The Tylt

VOTE NOW
Are you excited for the return of 'Doctor Who'?
#GimmeMoreWho
#GimmeMoreWho
#DoctorWhoIsDoomed
#DoctorWhoIsDoomed

“Doctor Who” fans—Whovians—are full of opinions. Every incarnation of the Doctor has been met with fan praise as well as those bemoaning how the show is doomed. The Chris Chibnall/Jodie Whittaker era has faced a heap of criticism, but there are plenty of fans who love the new direction and the fresh energy of a female Doctor. As the show is set to return in early 2020, are you looking forward to the next season?

Dataviz
Real-time Voting
Are you excited for the return of 'Doctor Who'?
#GimmeMoreWho
#DoctorWhoIsDoomed
#GimmeMoreWho

The last season saw a new writing team, new showrunner and groundbreaking casting for the Doctor. All this was a little too much for some fans, but the fact is Jodie Whittaker has made a great addition to the legacy. She’s bright, compassionate, goofy and energetic, reminiscent at times of predecessors Matt Smith and Peter Davison, but mostly her own novel interpretation. She comes with a very diverse set of companions, British citizens of African, South Asian and European backgrounds, and a variety of ages. Chris Chibnall’s take is less of the huge, sweeping story arcs that confused and frustrated Whovians during Steven Moffat’s era. This much change is bound to come with episodes that work and some that don’t. This has been true with every season of “Doctor Who.” But occasional fumbles aside, episodes like "Rosa" and "Demons of the Punjab" were excellent examples of Who as a means to observe and enjoy historical narratives. 

#DoctorWhoIsDoomed

While some fans (of the basement-dwelling neckbeard variety) opened their Cheeto-dusted maws to cry accusations of virtue signaling, misandry and other nonsensical claims at the Doctor’s change of sex, the fact remains that—incel whimpering aside—the show’s got some real problems. And Jodi Whittaker’s gender is not the issue. The problem is, simply, weak writing. The monsters aren’t scary. The stakes never really feel high enough. The companion role, meant to act as a proxy for the audience itself, is split three ways. The result is not that there’s a well realized Doctor and a larger-than-usual cast of great companions. No, the result is that none of these potentially excellent characters are ever really fleshed out, and as a result it’s just hard to care about what happens to any of them.

Lastly, though “Doctor Who” has always been more focused on the “fi” of sci-fi, it would be nice if the solutions to the problems in the shows at least felt a little more sciencey. The show has a longstanding tendency to be illogical and unscientific, and Chibnall isn’t even trying to address that. 

Check out The Tylt's geeky scavenger hunt at 2019 New York Comic Con.

VOTE NOW
Are you excited for the return of 'Doctor Who'?
#GimmeMoreWho
#GimmeMoreWho
#DoctorWhoIsDoomed
#DoctorWhoIsDoomed
© 2016 The Tylt
Use of and/or registration on any portion of this site constitutes acceptance of our  User Agreement  (updated 5/25/18) and  Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement  (updated 05/25/18).
© 2018 Advance Local Media LLC. All rights reserved  About Us.
The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed,transmitted,cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Advance Local.
Your California Privacy Rights