Who's really in the bubble: Liberals or conservatives?

Who's really in the bubble: Liberals or conservatives?

#LiberalBubble
#RightWingBubble
Join the conversation and vote below

Conservatives have long accused liberals and the mainstream media of living in a left-wing bubble, disconnected from the "real America," and data guru Nate Silver says they are rightHe points to Hillary Clinton's unprecedented loss to Donald Trump as the most glaring example of how out of touch so many journalists are. But liberals retort that right-wingers are the ones who are really insulated from reality—progressives aren't the ones denying science. So who's really in the bubble?

The Votes Are In!
#LiberalBubble
#RightWingBubble

The mainstream media's complete miss of Donald Trump's victory is perhaps the strongest indictment of liberal America's bubble and how disconnected they are from reality, as Nate Silver (who also got it wrong) wrote this week:

Much of The New York Times’s coverage...implied that Clinton’s odds were close to 100 percent. In an article on Oct. 17—more than three weeks before Election Day—they portrayed the race as being effectively over.
Image

David Mascriota agrees that the left wing inhabits a bubble—but that it's actually more permeable and less biased than the one rural white Christian America lives in:

 With typical idiocy and hypocrisy, American culture has issued a one-way, exclusive indictment against isolation for liberals and no one else.

In the wake of a stunning defeat, many say liberals need to seek out broader sources of news and information. With American media hubs located on the coasts, and social media feeds customized to show users opinions they already agree with, many are exhorting the left to get outside their echo chamber if they are ever going to understand why Trump won.

At AlterNet, a writer who "grew up in rural Christian white America" says it's conservatives whose bubble is impenetrableand whose belief system is divorced from reality:

"Telling 'urban elites' they need to understand rural Americans isn’t going to lead to a damn thing because it misses the causes of the problem....rural Christian white Americans are entrenched in fundamentalist belief systems; don’t trust people outside their tribe; have been force-fed a diet of misinformation and lies for decades."
Image

Gracy Olmstead at the Federalist thinks the election was the mainstream media's wake-up call:

A majority of the mainstream media expected a Clinton victory....Then their expectation turned to consternation, as Trump took the lead. They floundered, as they realized (perhaps some of them for the first time) how little they knew or understood the average American.

But critics say too many in the media are conflating white Midwestern America with "the average American." Since when are Brooklyn, Detroit, Miami, or Chicago and their denizens not "real America" or typical Americans? 

Cancel e81adef6e6553af1fd4ae2bf0fb5144e9639f08b71b0987074b13e549d2cbb48

GET OUR LATEST
COMMUNITY NEWS

Please provide a valid email