Which Ben and Jerry's flavor is better: Half Baked or Cherry Garcia? | The Tylt
Half Baked and Cherry Garcia are the two most popular Ben and Jerry's flavors. In celebration of Ben and Jerry's Free Cone Day, we're pitting the two head-to-head to see which one is really the best. Will it be Half Baked's dangerous combination of fudge brownies and cookie dough—or will it be the venerable classic Cherry Garcia? Pick your poison! 🍦

Half Baked bested Cherry Garcia in 2013 to become the top selling Ben and Jerry's ice cream flavor. It has literally everything you could want in ice cream—cookie dough, fudge brownies, chocolate ice cream and vanilla ice cream. It's the ice cream for every day and every person. It's a crowd pleaser. It's just really freaking good.
Cherry Garcia is one of Ben and Jerry's simpler flavor combinations, but that's not to say it's boring. Just think about it. Are cherries good? Yes. Is chocolate good? Yes. Is ice cream good? Yes.
Then it stands to reason that cherries, ice cream and chocolate would be some next level stuff. And it is. Who needs all that extra stuff when you have pure and simple goodness.
Don't take our word for it, here's what the fans think.
Ben & Jerry "half baked" is the best ice cream on the planet
— Pablo E$coBar (@Obey_jrock__) April 3, 2017
guy ahead of me @ Pavilions is just buying a Phish Food pint & a Cherry Garcia pint
— Owen Ellickson (@onlxn) March 29, 2017
he's on his phone rn so hey man if you see this i luv u