Is gentrification theft? | The Tylt

FINAL RESULTS
Culture
Is gentrification theft?
#GentrifyingIsTheft
A festive crown for the winner
#NeighborhoodsChange

After Denver's Ink Coffee posted a sign that read "Happily gentrifying the neighborhood since 2014" in a historically black neighborhood, many demanded a boycott. The owners have apologized, but critics argue the incident symbolizes a larger problem. White people don't recognize gentrification as the destructive removal of marginalized people of color from urban neighborhoods. Others say gentrification isn't evil. It's part of life, and actually benefits working-class communities. What do you think?

Dataviz
Real-time Voting
Is gentrification theft?
#GentrifyingIsTheft
#NeighborhoodsChange
#GentrifyingIsTheft

Here's the sign that sparked the controversy.

#GentrifyingIsTheft

Ink Coffee was vandalized after posting the controversial sign.

#NeighborhoodsChange

But others say gentrification isn't inherently evil, and that we can revitalize neighborhoods without displacing poor communities of color.

#NeighborhoodsChange
#GentrifyingIsTheft

Others argue gentrification is historically positive only for those who are privileged, property owners, and/or white people.

#GentrifyingIsTheft
#NeighborhoodsChange

Others say raging about gentrification and displacement is pointless and counterproductive.

#NeighborhoodsChange

Still others say this is just how the system works. You can't address displacement without addressing capitalism.

#GentrifyingIsTheft

Critics say anyone defending gentrification just benefits from that system.

#NeighborhoodsChange

This design group in Philadelphia argues that gentrification can be positive. The real issue is the scarcity of affordable housing in American cities.

Portraying the crisis of affordable housing as a pitched battle between gentrifiers and poor people is one of those proverbial false dichotomies. It is a dichotomy that comes from the premise that the stock of housing in livable neighborhoods is a finite -- indeed, shrinking -- resource, and thus the fight for this precious commodity as a Darwinian class struggle.
#GentrifyingIsTheft

In his book "How to Kill a City" Peter Moskowitz explains that gentrification "is not just about twenty-something white dudes with beards riding their fixed-gear bikes into unfamiliar neighborhoods." 

It is about profit and power, racism and violence on a massive scale. It is, in Moskowitz’s words, “the urban form of a new kind of capitalism.”
FINAL RESULTS
Culture
Is gentrification theft?
#GentrifyingIsTheft
A festive crown for the winner
#NeighborhoodsChange