Best sugar cookie: puffy cookies with icing or Pillsbury holiday-themed cookies? | The Tylt

Dataviz
Real-time Voting
Best sugar cookie: puffy cookies with icing or Pillsbury holiday-themed cookies?
#PuffyIcingCookiePls
#PillsburyCookiesPls
#PuffyIcingCookiePls

Lofthouse is the original maker of these cake-like classics, but you can find generic versions in most grocery stores. They come in every color combination imaginable and are the perfect pick-up-and-go item for any birthday, tailgate or holiday party you're attending.

Sure, people might not admit how much they love these cookies at first, but try this: Buy a pack, leave them on a table in your office, return one hour later and see if there are any left. Guaranteed, they'll be gone. Lofthouse describes its prized treats as:

An incredibly soft sugar cookie with a sweet and colorful frosting creates a mouth-watering combination that will keep you coming back for more. These bakery fresh treats are offered in many colorful varieties and seasonal flavors. Frostings include traditional colors appropriate for any occasion, as well as, bakery-inspired flavor combinations, like our Red Velvet, Carrot Cake, or our delicious Cinnamon Roll.

How could you turn down a cookie with that kind of description?

#PillsburyCookiesPls

The Pillsbury ready-to-bake sugar cookies are every holiday's greatest gift. Whether they feature Christmas trees, turkeys, ghosts or hearts, these cookies FLY off the shelves. If you happen across some pumpkin-themed Pillsbury cookies in July, you better snag them and save until Halloween, because by October, your grocery store will be sold out.

Not only are these cookies perfect in cookie-dough form, but they also offer the golden ratio of crisp, firm edges to soft, doughy interior. They are just the right size; every cookies is a bite-size piece of sugary, holiday goodness. 

#PuffyIcingCookiePls

The puffy, icing-laden sugar cookies let you play a game: Do you bite into it like a regular cookie, eat the edges around the icing first and then dive into the icing circle second, or do you lick the icing off like a cupcake and throw away the cookie part?

These cookies offer endless possibilities for enjoyment. They are the perfect treat-your-self purchase at the grocery store–there's a reason you can find them anywhere and everywhere. 

#PillsburyCookiesPls

There's simply no argument. Who wants a gallon of icing on top of their sugar cookie? Sugar cookies are meant to be pure. They do not depend on chocolate chunks, nuts or anything else to carry their flavor; they are the humble-but-bold member of the cookie family. Pillsbury's holiday cookies are the best tribute to the sugar cookie that a grocery store can offer.

Fans are adamant about how they feel: 

FINAL RESULTS
Culture
Best sugar cookie: puffy cookies with icing or Pillsbury holiday-themed cookies?
A festive crown for the winner